Netflix’s ‘Surprising’ Crime Drama Is Being Compared to Sherlock Holmes – And Fans Love Its Ending
A brilliant detective who can read people with extraordinary precision, seemingly impossible murder cases and a mystery that unfolds across multiple seasons have helped turn The Mentalist into a long-running crime drama favourite. Since its debut in September 2008, the series has developed a devoted following, with viewers continuing to praise its clever storytelling, memorable characters and satisfying finale.
Now available on Netflix in selected regions, the seven-season series is attracting fresh attention from crime drama fans. Created by Bruno Heller and starring Simon Baker and Robin Tunney, it has earned comparisons to Sherlock Holmes and The X-Files thanks to its unusual lead character and its blend of standalone investigations with a much larger mystery.

Simon Baker Plays a Detective With an Extraordinary Eye for Detail
At the centre of The Mentalist is Patrick Jane (Baker), a former television psychic who once convinced audiences that he possessed supernatural abilities. After publicly admitting that his psychic act was a fraud, he puts his exceptional observational skills and understanding of human behaviour to work as a consultant for law enforcement.
Jane’s unusual approach makes him an invaluable asset when investigating complicated crimes. He notices details others overlook, reads suspects’ emotions and uses psychological manipulation to expose lies. Rather than relying on conventional investigative methods, he often sets elaborate traps to make criminals reveal themselves.

But his work with the police has a deeply personal purpose. Jane is determined to track down Red John, the ruthless serial killer responsible for murdering his wife and daughter. His pursuit of the killer provides the show’s central storyline, gradually revealing more about the tragedy that shaped him.
Baker leads an accomplished ensemble cast featuring Robin Tunney, Tim Kang, Owain Yeoman, Amanda Righetti, Rockmond Dunbar, Joe Adler and Josie Loren.
His performance as Jane also earned significant industry recognition, including a Primetime Emmy nomination for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series in 2009.
Why Fans Keep Comparing It to Sherlock Holmes
With seven seasons and 151 episodes, The Mentalist has plenty of room to develop its characters and mysteries. While individual episodes often revolve around separate criminal investigations, the ongoing hunt for Red John gives the series a larger narrative that keeps viewers invested.
The comparisons to Sherlock Holmes are particularly understandable. Like the famous fictional detective, Jane relies on close observation, logical deductions and an extraordinary ability to recognise details that other people miss.

However, his methods are often more psychological. He studies how people react, identifies their emotional weaknesses and uses carefully planned mind games to push them into revealing the truth. His unconventional personality also brings moments of humour to stories that frequently deal with disturbing crimes.
One viewer explained that Jane reminded them more of Sherlock Holmes than Shawn Spencer from Psych, describing him as a more tortured version of the iconic detective. They also praised the writing, performances and cinematography, wishing the series had received even more recognition.
Other fans have highlighted the show’s ability to balance suspense, humour, unexpected twists, character development and long-running romantic storylines without losing momentum.
Viewers Are Especially Happy With the Series Finale

One of the strongest points in the show’s favour is its conclusion. While many long-running crime dramas struggle to bring their central mysteries to a satisfying close, The Mentalist has received considerable praise for the way it wraps up its story.
Some viewers have described the ending as one of the best they could have hoped for, while others have praised the final episodes for delivering the payoff that the characters and overarching storylines deserved.
One fan even revealed that their family had watched all seven seasons together three times, praising the series for its memorable dialogue, evolving characters, suspenseful investigations and numerous plot twists.
The show’s reception has also been positive among critics. Rotten Tomatoes currently lists a 90% Tomatometer score for the series. Reviews have highlighted its combination of humour, thoughtful characterisation and intricate mysteries, with particular praise for the balance between individual cases and the continuing Red John storyline.
A Crime Drama Worth Revisiting

More than a decade after its original run began, The Mentalist remains a compelling choice for viewers who enjoy intelligent mysteries and character-driven police procedurals.
Its appeal lies in the contrast between Jane’s playful, seemingly effortless confidence and the painful personal history driving his search for justice. Each investigation gives him another opportunity to demonstrate his remarkable abilities, while the larger mystery keeps the stakes high across the series.
For fans of Sherlock Holmes, The X-Files or clever detective dramas with long-running story arcs, this seven-season series offers plenty to discover.
** The Mentalist is available to stream on Netflix in selected regions. Availability varies by country.*